Assalamu Alaikum wa Rahmatullah,
I am written this because my heart it bothered by the fitnah that has occured in the west. Namely because of what is happening between Green Lane Masjid and Salafi Publications. And upon looking at the both the forums (Salafitalk and www.siratemustaqeem.com) I have realized some things.
1) Siratemustaqeem, who are associated with Ahya and Green Lane Masjids need more advice than the brothers in Salafi Publications for the following reasons:
1) Ill speech about the scholars. Namely Shaikh Ubaid Al Jaabiri, Shaikh Rabee’ Ibn Haadi Al Madkhali and Shaikh Muqbil Ibn Hadi. Also their ill speech about the two Yemeni students of knowledge Shaikh Zayed Al Wassabi and Shaikh Abu Amr Al Haajuri. Just because these scholars and students disagree with what they say.
2) Speaking without knowledge about the science of Jarh Wa Ta’deel and not looking at the speech of the Muhaditheen concerning this.
3) Calling our brothers in Salafi Publications Ghulaat and Hadaadis when they themselves take from websites such as Alathari (Shaikh Salih As Suhaimi gave a strong warning against this website) which is a known Hadaadi website.
Therefore, Inshallah I give this small advice for the sake of Allah ta’ala. Inshallah ta’ala I will start with part two which warns against speaking ill of the Ulama.